Nestled in the heart of Huntington, Melville is more than just a corporate hub or stop along Route 110—it’s a vibrant neighborhood with a rich and diverse food scene. Whether you’re seeking a comforting plate of pasta, hand-rolled sushi, fresh-baked bread, or a quick bite from a food truck, Melville offers something to please every palate and budget. Here’s your enthusiastic, insider’s guide to Melville’s must-try restaurants, cafés, bakeries, and local flavor traditions!
Main Street Marvels: Where to Begin
Most foodies start their exploration along the bustling corridor of Broadhollow Road (Route 110), which runs through the center of Melville and boasts an impressive range of dining options. But don’t stop there—venture down Old Country Road and other local side streets for lesser-known finds.
A Taste of Italy: Standout Italian Eateries
- Cirella’s Restaurant (14 Broadhollow Rd)
A Melville institution for over 30 years, Cirella’s draws crowds for its classic Italian-American fare and vibrant atmosphere. Favorites include the linguine with white clam sauce, wood-fired pizzas, and the velvety house-made tiramisu. Prices are midrange, making it a great spot for both casual dinners and special occasions.
- La Piazza (512 Walt Whitman Rd)
Family-friendly, bustling, and beloved for its brick oven pizzas and hearty pastas, La Piazza is a local favorite. Try their penne alla vodka or chicken scarpariello, and don’t miss the fresh mozzarella appetizer.
Sushi, Seafood, and Asian Gems
- T.O.A. Asian Fusion (200 Broadhollow Rd)
For sushi lovers, T.O.A. offers an inventive menu of rolls, sashimi, and Pan-Asian dishes in a modern, chic setting. Their “Chef’s Special Rolls” are a highlight, and the bento box lunch deals are a hit with the office crowd. Prices are moderate, but lunch specials make it budget-friendly.
- Hama Sushi (834 Walt Whitman Rd)
Tucked away just south of Melville’s business district, Hama Sushi serves fresh, beautifully presented sushi in a cozy, unpretentious space. Regulars rave about their spicy tuna roll and the seasonal Omakase menu.
American Classics and Steakhouse Experiences
- The Refuge (515 Broadhollow Rd)
Equal parts swanky steakhouse and lively bar, The Refuge is known for its upscale New American cuisine with Latin flair. Crowd-pleasers include the skirt steak, empanadas, and an impressive raw bar. Visit for weekend brunch to enjoy bottomless mimosas and Latin-inspired breakfast dishes.
- Blackstone Steakhouse (10 Pinelawn Rd)
Sleek and sophisticated, Blackstone is a splurge-worthy choice for steak lovers. Dry-aged steaks, fresh lobster, and decadent desserts are served in an ultra-modern setting. Expect to spend more here—perfect for celebrations or impressive business dinners.
International Flavors: Beyond the Basics
- Zim Zari Mexican & Latin Grill (4964 New York 110)
A fun twist on classic Tex-Mex, Zim Zari is famous for its fish tacos, tequila shrimp, and house-made margaritas. The laid-back, surf-themed décor makes it a great casual hangout, especially during their popular happy hour.
- Suburban Eats (Suburban Ave & Maxess Rd Intersection)
This sprawling gourmet deli and café is a daytime favorite. International sandwich options abound—think Italian panini, reubens, and Greek wraps—as well as homemade soups, fresh salads, and all-day breakfast classics. Perfect for a fast, quality lunch.
Cozy Cafés and Sweet Stops
- Village Coffee Market (865 Walt Whitman Rd)
A true neighborhood gathering place, Village Coffee Market is all about artisanal brews, excellent pastries, and a welcoming vibe. Try the nitro cold brew and a slice of their signature crumb cake. Prices are reasonable, and there’s free Wi-Fi for remote work sessions.
- Buttercooky Bakery (495 New York 110)
Renowned throughout Long Island, this old-school bakery is a must for anyone with a sweet tooth. Come for melt-in-your-mouth cookies, rainbow-layer cakes, elegant cannoli, and hand-crafted pastries. Locals order custom cakes here for every occasion.
Off-the-Beaten-Path: Hidden Gems and Food Trucks
- La Notte Lounge (775 Old Country Rd)
An elegant Italian lounge off the main drag, La Notte offers intimate vibes, exquisite house-made pasta, and a well-edited wine list. It’s often less crowded than the major Route 110 locations, making it ideal for date nights or small group dinners.
- Mr. Smith’s Food Truck (various locations, often near Pinelawn Rd & Broad Hollow Rd intersection)
For a quick, flavorful bite, track down Mr. Smith’s Food Truck serving up gourmet burgers, hand-cut fries, and rotating specials. The truffle fries are a cult favorite, and the owner’s hospitality keeps regulars coming back.
Seasonal Treats and Local Traditions
Melville also has seasonal farmers markets where vendors from Huntington and surrounding towns sell homemade pickles, jams, and produce—perfect for a taste of regional flavor! In fall, many locals make a tradition of visiting nearby farms for apple cider and pumpkin treats.
Tips for Exploring Melville’s Food Scene
- Lunch Crowd & Weeknight Deals: Many restaurants cater to Melville’s thriving office scene, so look for weekday lunch specials and early bird dinner deals.
- Weekend Reservations Recommended: Popular spots fill up, especially at Blackstone Steakhouse and The Refuge.
- Parking: Most eateries offer abundant on-site parking, but weekends can get busy—arrive early when possible.
Final Bite: Why Melville’s Food Scene Shines
Melville may fly under the radar compared to Huntington Village, but its rich culinary landscape offers surprises at every turn. Whether you’re out for a romantic dinner, a casual lunch, or an afternoon coffee, this neighborhood has you covered with top-quality, inventive eats for every taste.
Next time you find yourself driving down Route 110 or exploring Huntington, make it a point to linger in Melville—and come hungry!